Collateral Status Index

Maker Improvement Proposals Collateral Onboarding App
, ,
#1

This thread will act as an index to help people keep track of the current statuses of all proposed collateral types. The OP will be a summary of the current statuses. Replies will each deal with a single potential collateral type. I will be removing any other replies to this thread. I intend for it to be read-only. If you wish to discuss a collateral, post it in the appropriate application thread. This thread will be updated at least once every week (on Mondays.)

Last Updated: 10/08/2020, Added Assets, added domain work.

Statuses

Active

Collateral Package Entry Onboarding Process
[ETH-A] - MCD Launch
[BAT-A] - MCD Launch
[wBTC-A] - Emergency Process
[USDC-A] - Emergency Process
[USDC-B] - Weekly Cycle
[TUSD-A] Entry Weekly Cycle
[KNC-A] Entry Weekly Cycle
[ZRX-A] Entry Weekly Cycle
[MANA-A] Entry Monthly Cycle

Planned

Asset Entry Risk Oracle Legal Smart Contracts
[LRC] Entry Domain Work Domain Work — Domain Work
[PAX] Entry — Domain Work — Domain Work
[USDT] Entry — Domain Work — Domain Work
[LINK] Entry — — — Domain Work

Greenlight Status

Asset Entry Risk Oracle Smart Contracts Legal Community
[CF-DROP] Entry - - - - Greenlit
[COMP] Entry - - - - Greenlit
[EURS] Entry - - - - Greenlit
[HUSD] Entry - - - - Greenlit
[LINK] Entry - - - - Greenlit
[LRC] Entry - - - - Greenlit
[PAX] Entry - - - - Greenlit
[PAXG] Entry - - - - Greenlit
[PC-DROP] Entry - - - - Greenlit
[renBTC] Entry - - - - Greenlit
[tBTC] Entry - - - - Greenlit
[UNI-V1-DAI] Entry - Deferred - - Greenlit
[USDT] Entry - - - - Greenlit
[WKT] Entry - - - - Greenlit
[BUSD] Entry - - - - Due 17/08/20
[CHI] Entry - - - - Due 17/08/20
[HBTC] Entry - - - - Due 17/08/20
[HTC-DROP] Entry - - - - Due 17/08/20
[GUSD] Entry - - - - Due 17/08/20
[NS-DROP] Entry - - - - Due 17/08/20
[REN] Entry - - - - Due 17/08/20
[TGBP] Entry - - - - Due 17/08/20
[TCAD] Entry - - - - Due 17/08/20
[TAUD] Entry - - - - Due 17/08/20
[UNI-V2-DAI-ETH] Entry - - - - Due 17/08/20
[UNI-V2-USDC-ETH] Entry - - - - Due 17/08/20
[ARCA] Entry - - - - Due 21/09/20
[renZEC] Entry - - - - Due 21/09/20
[UMA] Entry - - - - Due 21/09/20
[$CHZ] Entry - Rejected - - Deferred
[AMPL] Entry - - - - Deferred
[C20] Entry - - - - Deferred
[DMM] Entry - Rejected - - Deferred
[ENJ] Entry - - - - Deferred
[FIAT] Entry - - - - Deferred
[FTM] Entry - - - - Deferred
[LEND] Entry - - - - Deferred
[MATIC] Entry - - - - Deferred
[WiV] Entry - - - - Deferred
21 Likes
Collateral Priority Poll
MIP12c2-SP2: Domain Work Requirements for KNC
MIP12c2-SP1: Domain Work Requirements for ZRX
Maker Relay Ep. 5
TUSD Update: TrustToken Response to Implementation Concerns
Governance at a glance
Collateral Onboarding Call (MIPs #6-12): Discussion and Review of Collateral Onboarding Process
MIP0c12-SP2: Subproposal for Core Personnel Onboarding (Governance Facilitator)
[Agenda/Discussion] Scientific Governance and Risk #103 - Thursday, July 30 4:00 PM UTC
Weekly MIPs Update #5
Be selective of what is allowed to be collateral
[Agenda/Discussion] Scientific Governance and Risk - Thursday, June 11 9AM PST (4:00 PM UTC)
MIP12c2-SP3: Domain Work Requirements for the Onboarding of MANA
MIP12c2-SP4: Domain Work Requirements for LRC
[Agenda/Discussion] Scientific Governance and Risk #100 - Thursday, July 9 9AM PST (4:00 PM UTC)
Discussion of collateral onboarding process
Idea for visualizing progress for collateral onboarding
#5

[FIAT]

MIP6 Application: [FIAT] - A basket of stablecoins that carry the same risk profile
MIP9 Poll: https://vote.makerdao.com/polling-proposal/qmfpnnbpdsrvwqdyuwvjbre8fqktcyldkolat8zp2bfcvf
MIP12 Subproposal: -

Status

Awaiting Community Greenlight

Community Greenlight

Status: Deferred
Score: -4,978.58 MKR
Turnout: 46,564.63 MKR
Date: 08/06/20

Domain Greenlight

Risk: -
Oracle: -
Smart Contracts: -
Legal: -

Domain Work

Risk: -
Oracle: -
Smart Contracts: -
Legal: -

1 Like
#6

[PC-DROP]

MIP6 Application: [PC-DROP] MIP6 Application: Paperchain DROP: Tokenized Music Streaming Invoices
MIP9 Poll: https://vote.makerdao.com/polling-proposal/qma4vwuf9xmbzcyyfc6v7kiattvewa1sxp9biaxngeefvu
MIP12 Subproposal: -

Status

Awaiting Domain Greenlight

Community Greenlight

Status: Greenlit
Score: 81,617.21‬ MKR
Turnout: 85,509.45 MKR
Date: 08/06/20

Domain Greenlight

Risk: Overdue (15/05/20)
Oracle: Overdue (15/05/20)
Smart Contracts: Overdue (15/05/20)
Legal: Overdue (15/05/20)

Domain Work

Risk: -
Oracle: -
Smart Contracts: -
Legal: -

1 Like
Weekly MIPs Update #8
#7

[CF-DROP]

MIP6 Application: [CF-DROP] MIP6 Application: ConsolFreight DROP: Tokenized Freight Shipping Invoices
MIP9 Poll: https://vote.makerdao.com/polling-proposal/qmtfpmuueop6iwnl1aqvuzhcnxyyxzfdob8jh6upyvxzns
MIP12 Subproposal: -

Status

Awaiting Domain Greenlight

Community Greenlight

Status: Greenlit
Score: 60,533.45 MKR
Turnout: 64,425.69 MKR
Date: 08/06/20

Domain Greenlight

Risk: Overdue (15/05/20)
Oracle: Overdue (15/05/20)
Smart Contracts: Overdue (15/05/20)
Legal: Overdue (15/05/20)

Domain Work

Risk: -
Oracle: -
Smart Contracts: -
Legal: -

1 Like
#8

[DMM]

MIP6 Application: [DMM] Proposal for Collateral Onboarding of DMM mTokens
MIP9 Poll: https://vote.makerdao.com/polling-proposal/qmfv8hybmp7sfmzgdgtpwkpbgzqjmnx6iimlxm3rqpdsut
MIP12 Subproposal: -

Status

Awaiting Community Greenlight

Community Greenlight

Status: Deferred
Score: -19,746.64 MKR
Turnout: 54,048.78 MKR
Date: 08/06/20

Domain Greenlight

Risk: -
Oracle: Rejected (15/05/20)
Smart Contracts: -
Legal: -

Domain Work

Risk: -
Oracle: -
Smart Contracts: -
Legal: -

#9

[UNI-V1-DAI]

MIP6 Application: [UNI-V1-DAI] Uniswap Dai Liquidity Token Collateral Application
MIP9 Poll: https://vote.makerdao.com/polling-proposal/qmuunouk9gf6jnpqhfyyxzhm1cxxef92bfcngj5jvq3gaa
MIP12 Subproposal: -

Status

Awaiting Domain Greenlight

Community Greenlight

Status: Greenlit
Score: 24,559.46 MKR
Turnout: 30,267.72 MKR
Date: 08/06/20

Domain Greenlight

Risk: Overdue (15/05/20)
Oracle: Deferred pending supply growth and oracle stack updates (14/05/20)
Smart Contracts: Overdue (15/05/20)
Legal: Overdue (15/05/20)

Domain Work

Risk: -
Oracle: -
Smart Contracts: -
Legal: -

2 Likes
#10

[$CHZ]

MIP6 Application: [$CHZ] - Proposal for Collateral Onboarding - Chiliz / Sports x DeFi
MIP9 Poll: https://vote.makerdao.com/polling-proposal/qmx9ntps5gnkfeoueqjvziwvskip3rxd3jr41khtq5px3w
MIP12 Subproposal: -

Status

Awaiting Community Greenlight

Community Greenlight

Status: Deferred
Score: -7,206.45 MKR
Turnout: 42,468.92 MKR
Date: 08/06/20

Domain Greenlight

Risk: -
Oracle: Rejected (15/05/20)
Smart Contracts: -
Legal: -

Domain Work

Risk: -
Oracle: -
Smart Contracts: -
Legal: -

1 Like
#11

[TUSD]

MIP6 Application: [TUSD] - Adding as collateral to MCD (Second Application)
MIP9 Poll: https://vote.makerdao.com/polling-proposal/qmep2rvomgptgeq9ehrnxmzan5r3gpxw47w3jtutzy9gc5
MIP12 Subproposal: -

Status

Active

Community Greenlight

Status: Greenlit
Score: 21,345.01‬ MKR
Turnout: 21,348.35 MKR
Date: 28/05/20*

* Note that this greenlight poll lasted only two days. However, considering that polls to onboard TUSD also passed at a similar time outside of the MIPs process, for all intents and purposes, this should be considered to have passed Community Greenlight.

Domain Greenlight

Risk: Overdue (15/05/20)
Oracle: Greenlit (14/05/20)
Smart Contracts: Overdue (15/05/20)
Legal: Overdue (15/05/20)

Domain Work

Risk: [TUSD] Proposal for Collateral Onboarding
Oracle: -
Smart Contracts: -
Legal: -

2 Likes
#12

[ZRX]

MIP6 Application: [ZRX] - MCD collateral application
MIP9 Poll: https://vote.makerdao.com/polling-proposal/qmtmbjn5jvgv7icpbbukzzvepmdahvcd7qlupt82wbya3h
MIP12 Subproposal: -

Status

Active

Community Greenlight

Status: Greenlit
Score: 36,633.04‬ MKR
Turnout: 47,364.30 MKR
Date: 08/06/20

Domain Greenlight

Risk: Overdue (15/05/20)
Oracle: Greenlit (14/05/20)
Smart Contracts: Overdue (15/05/20)
Legal: Overdue (15/05/20)

Domain Work

Risk: [ZRX] MIP12c2-SP1 Collateral Onboarding Risk Evaluation
Oracle: -
Smart Contracts: -
Legal: -

1 Like
[ZRX] - MCD collateral application
#13

[MANA]

MIP6 Application: [MANA] - MCD Application by Decentraland
MIP9 Poll: https://vote.makerdao.com/polling-proposal/qmwlgzhbhirn6paevskhvkhfckggsjzn4alkckzgf1dbwb
MIP12 Subproposal: https://github.com/makerdao/mips/blob/Accepted/MIP12/MIP12c2-Subproposals/MIP12c2-SP3.md

Status

Active

Community Greenlight

Status: Greenlit
Score: 26,651.53 MKR
Turnout: 32,309.15 MKR
Date: 08/06/20

Domain Greenlight

Risk: Overdue (15/05/20)
Oracle: Greenlit (14/05/20)
Smart Contracts: Overdue (15/05/20)
Legal: Overdue (15/05/20)

Domain Work

Risk: [MANA] MIP12c2-SP2 Collateral Onboarding Risk Evaluation
Oracle: MIP10c3-SP3 Proposal: MANAUSD Oracle (Collateral Onboarding Oracle Assessment)
Smart Contracts: [MANA] ERC20 Token Smart Contract Domain Team Assessment
Legal: -

#14

[tBTC]

MIP6 Application: [TBTC] Proposal for Collateral Onboarding - tBTC
MIP9 Poll: https://vote.makerdao.com/polling-proposal/qmxgvhjmutgq87bbimwwa7lguxqeumgqs49zmrkgk6vdxu
MIP12 Subproposal: -

Status

Awaiting Domain Greenlight

Community Greenlight

Status: Greenlit
Score: 18,368.5 MKR
Turnout: 30,655.36 MKR
Date: 08/06/20

Domain Greenlight

Risk: Overdue (15/05/20)
Oracle: Overdue (15/05/20)
Smart Contracts: Overdue (15/05/20)
Legal: Overdue (15/05/20)

Domain Work

Risk: -
Oracle: -
Smart Contracts: -
Legal: -

2 Likes
#15

[FTM]

MIP6 Application: [FTM] - Collateral Onboarding Application
MIP9 Poll: https://vote.makerdao.com/polling-proposal/qmemnm3prcsgtmntkwvuhczqxc1zqwwvfhpgn33vhjs6fs
MIP12 Subproposal: -

Status

Awaiting Community Greenlight

Community Greenlight

Status: Deferred
Score: -40,928.31
Turnout: 41,348.31 MKR
Date: 08/06/20

Domain Greenlight

Risk: -
Oracle: -
Smart Contracts: -
Legal: -

Domain Work

Risk: -
Oracle: -
Smart Contracts: -
Legal: -

#16

[KNC]

MIP6 Application: [KNC] MIP6 MCD Application: Kyber Network KNC
MIP9 Poll: https://vote.makerdao.com/polling-proposal/qmzp6crkyuwmwrx9whjk8gbw4cfpqkoz8jthaigmczjbak
MIP12 Subproposal: -

Status

Active

Community Greenlight

Status: Greenlit
Score: 37,428.61 MKR
Turnout: 37,428.22 MKR
Date: 06/07/20

Domain Greenlight

Risk: Due 26/05/20
Oracle: Greenlit (26/05/20)
Smart Contracts: Due 26/05/20
Legal: Due 26/05/20

Domain Work

Risk: [KNC] MIP12c2-SP2 Collateral Onboarding Risk Evaluation
Oracle: -
Smart Contracts: -
Legal: -

1 Like
#17

[LEND]

MIP6 Application: [LEND] MIP6 Collateral Onboarding - AAVE
MIP9 Poll: https://vote.makerdao.com/polling-proposal/qmfhnsk3vaahvf3dwaujzwczevrne9usfbblogl52ubqrz
MIP12 Subproposal: -

Status

Awaiting Community Greenlight

Community Greenlight

Status: Deferred
Score: -31,382.2 MKR*
Turnout: 39,635.23 MKR
Date: 06/07/20

Domain Greenlight

Risk: -
Oracle: -
Smart Contracts: -
Legal: -

Domain Work

Risk: [LEND] MIP12c2-SP2 Collateral Onboarding Risk Evaluation
Oracle: MIP10c3-SP4 Proposal: LENDUSD Oracle (collateral-onboarding)
Smart Contracts: [LEND] ERC20 Token Smart Contract Domain Team Assessment
Legal: -

* Note that different polling frontends reported slightly different values for votes. In this case the difference is small and does not change the greenlight outcome.

2 Likes
#18

[MATIC]

MIP6 Application: [MATIC] - MCD Application (Matic Network)
MIP9 Poll: https://vote.makerdao.com/polling-proposal/qmpilr6zwthsc6lpf4jnpkknqwywqlpnuvoa3jakwkfyca
MIP12 Subproposal: -

Status

Awaiting Community Greenlight

Community Greenlight

Status: Deferred
Score: -13,254.14 MKR
Turnout: 21,192.63 MKR
Date: Started 06/07/20

Domain Greenlight

Risk: -
Oracle: -
Smart Contracts: -
Legal: -

Domain Work

Risk: -
Oracle: -
Smart Contracts: -
Legal: -

#19

[PAXG]

MIP6 Application: [PAXG] - PAX Gold MIP6 collateral application
MIP9 Poll: https://vote.makerdao.com/polling-proposal/qmu8ty14qpgpy86dtwycpasywxgl4m4kwz7fyatyg3bwwm
MIP12 Subproposal: -

Status

Awaiting Domain Greenlight

Community Greenlight

Status: Greenlit
Score: 37,702.59 MKR
Turnout: 38,009.39 MKR
Date: 06/07/20

Domain Greenlight

Risk: Due 20/07/20
Oracle: Due 20/07/20
Smart Contracts: Due 20/07/20
Legal: Due 20/07/20

Domain Work

Risk: -
Oracle: -
Smart Contracts: [PAXG] ERC20 Token Smart Contract Domain Community Assessment
Legal: -

2 Likes
#20

[LINK]

MIP6 Application: [LINK] Collateral Onboarding Application
MIP9 Poll: https://vote.makerdao.com/polling-proposal/qmaleb9ryc4xmhkjlm9ailxtxroft6khjejcd7otm6yf13
MIP12 Subproposal: -

Status

Awaiting Domain Greenlight

Community Greenlight

Status: Greenlit
Score: 35,194.59 MKR
Turnout: 38,354.59 MKR
Date: 06/07/20

Domain Greenlight

Risk: Due 20/07/20
Oracle: Due 20/07/20
Smart Contracts: Due 20/07/20
Legal: Due 20/07/20

Domain Work

Risk: -
Oracle: -
Smart Contracts: [LINK] ERC20 Token Smart Contract Technical Assessment
Legal: -

4 Likes
Using Chainlink Oracles for LINK-USD
#21

[ENJ]

MIP6 Application: [ENJ] MIP6 MCD Application: Enjin
MIP9 Poll: https://vote.makerdao.com/polling-proposal/qmrt8b8jwrynwiucvbpqmofxpqiskwyryszvdcqaka8xrz
MIP12 Subproposal: -

Status

Awaiting Community Greenlight

Community Greenlight

Status: Deferred
Score: -37,108.88 MKR*
Turnout: 37,482.06 MKR
Date: 06/07/20

Domain Greenlight

Risk: -
Oracle: -
Smart Contracts: -
Legal: -

Domain Work

Risk: -
Oracle: -
Smart Contracts: -
Legal: -

* Note that different polling frontends reported slightly different values for votes. In this case the difference is small and does not change the greenlight outcome.

#22

[WKT]

MIP6 Application: [WKT] MIP6 MCD Application: WizKey Token - Insured tokenized invoices
MIP9 Poll: https://vote.makerdao.com/polling-proposal/qmrzr4xwqxaiznubckiquwbyffffgkpdjrngczcwwfcdr7
MIP12 Subproposal: -

Status

Awaiting Domain Greenlight

Community Greenlight

Status: Greenlit
Score: 2,153.48 MKR
Turnout: 39,481.17 MKR
Date: 06/07/20

Domain Greenlight

Risk: Due 20/07/20
Oracle: Due 20/07/20
Smart Contracts: Due 20/07/20
Legal: Due 20/07/20

Domain Work

Risk: -
Oracle: -
Smart Contracts: -
Legal: -

2 Likes
#23

[PAX]

MIP6 Application: [PAX] - PAX MIP6 collateral application
MIP9 Poll: https://vote.makerdao.com/polling-proposal/qmel3ws4qh7cxuhrappyn4uktisdgq76ftrq6v3symgxvp
MIP12 Subproposal: -

Status

Awaiting Domain Greenlight

Community Greenlight

Status: Greenlit
Score: 38,857.29 MKR
Turnout: 38,857.29 MKR
Date: 03/08/20

Domain Greenlight

Risk: -
Oracle: -
Smart Contracts:-
Legal: -

Domain Work

Risk: -
Oracle: MIP10c3-SP7 Proposal: PAXUSD Oracle (Collateral Onboarding Oracle Assessment)
Smart Contracts: [PAXUSD] ERC20 Token Smart Contract Technical Assessment
Legal: -