So Juan made this comment recently as part of a larger post in the Facilitator Offboarding thread. I don’t want to put the focus too much on Juan though, since this is a sentiment I’ve seen come up a few times, from a few different people. So please take this as a wider commentary on culture within the DAO and the relationship between MKR Holders and Core Unit Contributors.
I want to be clear up front that I don’t think fear should be a component of any healthy relationship, be it between individuals, groups, whatever. A community in which one group fears another is not a healthy community, a workplace where one group fears another is not a healthy (or productive) workplace.
Fear distracts people from the jobs they are being paid to do, and leads them to spend more effort on covering themselves, protecting themselves, and building powerbases such that they no longer need to fear. In a word, it leads to politics.
Fear is one of the worst parts of some traditional organizations, and is something that I personally will not tolerate if it becomes a norm within MakerDAO.
When it comes to ‘any MKR Holder’ it’s also nonsensical. There is frankly no reason to fear any individual MKR Holder because they hold no individual authority.
I believe that MKR Holders as a collective fundamentally should not give contributors to the DAO reason to fear them for the reasons above. It degrades productivity, and will result in a lack of transparency. If people are afraid of what you will do with information about them, they will not provide you with that information.
More nuanced is the issue of respect within MakerDAO.
Respect is generally agreed to be something that must be earned. Taking this definition, it is ridiculous to say that contributors owe respect to every MKR Holder.
What is important (and I believe that generally MakerDAO is fantastic at this) is that everyone within this community respects each others humanity. The default should always be to engage with each other politely and respectfully regardless of who is holding MKR, who contributes time to the DAO and people who are new or external to the core community. This comes back to a principle I’m very fond of, which is to ‘assume good faith.’ The assumption should always be that the person engaging with you is coming to you in good faith.
However. Individuals are ultimately responsible for their own actions. Behave well, honorably, and respectfully to others regardless of their status relative to your own, and you will find yourself gaining the respect of others. Behave otherwise, and you will find that people come to lose that respect in you. There is no special quality that makes MKR Holders exempt from the social consequences of their actions.
There are many MKR Holders I respect deeply, there are others that I do not, this is a natural and reasonable response to engaging with other human beings. No one is owed respect separate from their actions.
What is important to the functioning of MakerDAO is that all involved respect and abide by the process of collective governance. Together MKR Holders possess power over Core Units, but only collectively and through the operation of the agreed governance processes.
The example of the unhappy man at the DMV comes to mind, complaining about the wait and shouting:
I pay my taxes! I’m your boss, you work for me!
The man is correct (abstractly), but he is not permitted to have his way and skip the line because the DMV serves all citizens, not just this one man.
It is fundamentally incorrect for an individual citizen to fire an elected member of a government, because it undermines the power of the electorate as a whole. This is also true within MakerDAO.
Contributors serve all MKR Holders, regardless of their relative MKR weight. Individual MKR Holders do not have the authority to dismiss individuals elected to position by MakerDAO governance processes because it undermines the collective power of all MKR Holders. This is critical for everyone in the DAO to keep in mind, both elected individuals, and MKR Holders.
Many individuals within MakerDAO possess influence over the community, whether due to their actions, their positions, or their reputation. This is entirely natural and is an unavoidable consequence of humans working together. But influence is not the same as authority. Individuals in the DAO can ask you to do something, they can try to convince you to do something (and since you are respecting each other as human beings you should genuinely consider it), but they cannot force you to do something.
This is how it should be. This is what makes it different. This is what makes it better.