No amount of compensation is going to make those things go away, frankly.
Expecting 24% back is unreasonable in my view. Successful auctions on the day returned around at best 11% of collateral to Vaults. That gives us the best idea of what Vault Holders could have expected had there been enough (but not copious amounts) of keeper liquidity.
I’d actually like to split the difference between 0% and 11%, and return 5.5%. Given that responsibility for the outcome is shared between like 5 different entities (of which MKR Token Holders are only one) this still feels more than generous.
On another point those arguments for compensation represent a subset of the communities opinions. I didn’t agree with them as stated, but I still voted in favour. I just want to be clear they should not be considered the canonical source of truth on what the responsibilities of MKR Token Holders are, or what their reasons for voting in favor would be.
Regarding what the poll looks like, we’ll do our best to structure it to capture as much signal as possible, as efficiently as possible. We’ll also try to make sure it’s objective as possible. I’m sure full compensation of 24% will be on the poll. I’m also fairly sure that 0% compensation will be on the poll, given that we now have more information regarding auction effectiveness and the cost of compensation than we did previously, and that this new information may have caused people to change their minds. Probably we’ll see a few options between those extremes too.