The second half of 2021 has brought a cooling down of the once sizzling sector know as Decentralized Finance (DeFi). The DeFi Pulse Index, which tracks tokens such as Maker, Aave, Uniswap, Compound, Yearn, and Sushi has dropped over 60%++ in the past seven months. Compared to the performance of layer 1 protocols such as Ethereum, Avalanche, Solana, and NEAR, it is a lagging sector.
While the recent sharp drops in the Crypto markets have also hurt DeFi 2.0 applications and the floor price of non-fungible tokens (NFTs), value of OG DeFi applications continue to stay depressed, although Total Value-Locked has increased over 100%++ since June 1, 2021 per DeFi Llama. This is probably affected by investors favoring NFTs (digital art), and DeFi 2.0 applications like OHM. This comparison of the price of Maker’s Governance token MKR to OHM’s Market Cap and TVL is at first sight very compelling to the human eye, but more than likely misleading:
When we flip the script to the market cap/TVL of MakerDAO–It can be misleading and send the noobs over to OHM:
Now, as Maker Community members we will argue to our death-beds that MKR is undervalued and trading with a Price to Earnings of less than 20 with Annual Profits currently estimated to be $130M plus. But to the DeFi 2.0 and NFT fanatics MKR facts are irrelevant, as the ponzinomics and Up-Only meme is more relevant.
To some early adapters of DeFi, Compound will forever be remembered as “the first Mohican” of Governance Token Liquidity Mining. Alex Kroger recently wrote an article about the impact that the Compound Liquidity Mining program has provided for the usage of the COMP token. He reminds us that the original intention of the COMP token liquidity mining program was “to distribute governance tokens to users who would then become active participants in protocol governance.” In the article Alex describes that:
“top 100 accounts have accrued 809K COMP (roughly $271M at current prices), representing 69% of all COMP mined. Yet very few of these accounts are COMP hodlers. Only 19% have kept greater than 1% of the COMP they claimed; only 7% have kept greater than 50%. Do recipients of liquidity mining rewards retain an economic interest in Compound protocol? No.”
So, what has gone wrong? What can we learn from this experience? Well, Alex references the write-up by Jacob Phillips, “Governance Mining — liquidity mining for human capital” – which leads me to the story of the Pudgy Penguins.
Over the weekend of December 10th, a Community Member and Moderator of Pudgy Penguins named 0xDarth took to Twitter Spaces and announced his discontent and the unprofessional leadership of the project’s founders. The main takeaway from this drama was the lack of compensation for human capital. Apparently 0xDarth was being compensated 0.10 to 0.25 ETH for his hard work and dedication to the Pudgy Penguins community. As Jacob stated in his article:
" no one is stepping up to lead teams and contribute because the incentives are weak or nonexistent. As a result, products move slowly, teams don’t grow, and existing DAOs risk being replaced by new teams that move faster."
Speaking of stepping-up, Frog Nation and Abracadabra community member Daniele Sesta has proposed to reinvent Sushi. An application that once held over $8B in TVL across many blockchains, has now finds itself with multiple-products that I can’t even understand what each one of them provides. Sushi also finds itself in a whirlwind of inner-obstructions that has recently led to the write-up by their former CTO called " My Failures in Leadership at Sushi " But with the community still in tacked, Daniele is proposing that Sushi goes back to it’s Old School ways of being a DEX:
Proposed Changes to the Project:
- Full focus on DEX
- Change of Tokenomics
- Change in parts of Team
- Deprecating Legal Entity
As DeFi Governance Tokens will more than likely continue to lag in popularity, let’s be thankful as MKR hodlers that we do have a Token Burning mechanism in place. The recent discussion by the Aave Community to incentivize utility for AAVE tokens reminds me that things could be worse. So the next time you think the Maker Community is behind the “Curve”, just remember that MakerDAO is light years ahead of the competition. Let’s keep that way.
Ladies and Germs. Like-it-or-not, the multi-blockchain future is here. Thankfully the people who inspire us to think beyond our own intellectual boundaries are here to teach us and help us understand the next frontier. This excellent research paper by the likes of the Ethereum Foundation, Flashbots Research, Movr, and Gauntlet is this Week’s Must Read:
Have a profitable and happy healthy week everybody!